Could it possibly be Hopeful or Pessimistic? Customers with discover Faulkner battle to square his tragic and you can, on the surface at the very least, pessimistic works especially those away from their early so you’re able to center profession including As i Lay Perishing for the hopeful comments of your own Nobel Honor speech. Particular argue that the new address is simple rhetoric (the sort you to definitely Addie Bundren would deplore), a public posturing that has absolutely nothing importance on higher fiction. Others take on the newest feelings of your own message since the legitimate and you can polite. The truth get lay somewhere in between, due to the fact Once i Lay Passing away seems to demonstrate. You will find no concern that the Bundrens (whoever name’s suggestive out-of “burdens”) endure an organic catastrophe, social scorn, and you can criminal disagreement inside their own members of the family to succeed in its endeavor to come back Addie home to Jefferson having burial.
And you can, at the very least during the an effective legalistic experience, the household product was recovered in the bottom towards purchase out-of a different wife and mommy. But the Bundrens’ victory are considerably jeopardized by heartbreaking effects of its journey. Anse possess another type of spouse and you will a collection of false white teeth, although rest of the relatives appear to have forgotten a lot more than just a father or mother: Darl was stated insane which will be artificially delivered to the fresh asylum in Jackson; Dewey Dell provides don’t safe their own abortion and, regarding take to, could have been sexually victimized again; Dollars could have been crippled, perhaps forever; Jewel has lost their horse; and you will Vardaman provides failed to actually see, way less acquire, the fresh toy instruct he covets.